InTurnAll

Introduction

The idea that animals might believe in a higher power or an afterlife challenges our anthropocentric view of religion and spirituality. Humans have long claimed exclusive domain over such abstract concepts, but emerging observations from ethology, neuroscience, and comparative religion suggest otherwise. While animals can’t articulate beliefs through language, their behaviors—ranging from ritualistic dances to elaborate mourning practices—hint at proto-religious experiences. This article explores why it’s plausible for non-human animals to harbor something akin to faith in God or an afterlife, drawing on scientific evidence of shared cognitive and emotional capacities. Though speculative, these insights reveal that spirituality may not be uniquely human but rooted in evolutionary biology.

The Foundations: Animal Cognition and Emotional Depth

At the core of any belief system is the ability to experience emotions, form mental representations, and engage with the unknown. Animals possess complex cognitive abilities that could support rudimentary beliefs. For instance, many species demonstrate self-awareness, theory of mind (understanding others’ perspectives), and emotional responses like grief or awe—prerequisites for contemplating the divine or what lies beyond death. 12

Neuroscience points to the limbic system, a brain structure shared between humans and animals, as the seat of mystical experiences. This system governs emotions and can produce feelings of oneness, wonder, or transcendence. Studies suggest that animals, including dogs, cats, chimpanzees, and elephants, might undergo similar states due to physiological similarities, such as near-death experiences involving visions of light or profound joy. 13 21 If humans interpret these as spiritual, why couldn’t animals? Ethologist Marc Bekoff argues that emotional continuity across species implies animals could feel a sense of mystery or connection to something greater, laying the groundwork for belief in a divine force or posthumous existence. 22

Ritual Behaviors: Echoes of Worship and Awe

One compelling argument for animal belief in God comes from observed rituals that mirror human religious practices. Chimpanzees, for example, have been filmed throwing rocks into tree hollows, creating stone piles reminiscent of human altars or cairns. These actions lack obvious survival benefits, suggesting they might stem from awe or reverence—perhaps a primitive form of worship. 15 16 19 Jane Goodall documented chimpanzees “dancing” ecstatically during rainstorms or near waterfalls, entering trance-like states that evolutionary psychologists link to early human rituals for social bonding or spiritual connection. 10 20 22

Other primates, like baboons, engage in silent contemplation by water bodies, forming what anthropologist Barbara Smuts calls a “baboon sangha”—a communal, meditative gathering evoking spiritual presence. 22 These behaviors aren’t mere instincts; they involve intentionality and cultural transmission, passed down through groups, much like religious traditions. If God represents an ultimate mystery or force, animals’ displays of fascination with natural phenomena (e.g., fire dances in chimpanzees) could be interpreted as proto-belief in a higher power. 20

Mourning and Death Rituals: Indications of an Afterlife Concept

Belief in an afterlife often arises from confronting mortality. Animals exhibit mourning behaviors that suggest they grapple with death in ways implying hope or reverence for the departed. Elephants, renowned for their intelligence, perform elaborate funerals: covering deceased kin with mud, leaves, flowers, and foliage, and revisiting bones years later. 10 20 19 These acts parallel Neanderthal burials and could reflect a belief in rebirth or an ongoing spiritual presence.

Dolphins and orcas stay with dead pod members for days, protecting bodies and displaying grief. 10 20 A notable case involved an orca mother carrying her calf’s carcass for 17 days, a “tour of grief” that fostered social cohesion. 20 Corvids like crows hold vigils around carcasses, gathering in silence—a ritual that might honor the dead or contemplate loss. 10 20 Magpies even place grass beside fallen comrades, hinting at symbolic gestures. 22

Such responses go beyond survival instincts, involving empathy and memory. If humans derive afterlife beliefs from grief, animals’ affective reactions—rooted in the same limbic wiring—could foster similar intuitions about continuity after death. 13 21

Interdisciplinary Perspectives: Blending Science, Philosophy, and Religion

From a scientific viewpoint, cognitive ethology emphasizes mental continuity: animals’ “Umwelten” (unique perceptual worlds) allow diverse affective engagements with the world, potentially including spiritual ones. 22 Philosopher Donovan O. Schaefer argues that animal religion manifests through embodied affects rather than doctrines—praise or awe as instinctive impulses, not creeds. 22

Religious traditions also support this possibility. In Islam, animals praise God instinctually; in Hinduism, they achieve spiritual liberation; and biblical texts include animals in divine covenants. 7 22 Pew Research indicates widespread human belief in animal spirits, reflecting intuitive recognition of their spiritual potential. 9

Critics argue these behaviors lack symbolic language or intentionality, confining religion to humans. 11 14 Yet, scholars like Aaron Gross counter that rigid definitions exclude valid experiences, urging a broader view where animal rituals challenge human exceptionalism. 19

Conclusion

While we can’t prove animals believe in God or an afterlife—lacking their testimony—the evidence from rituals, mourning, and shared neurology makes it entirely possible. These behaviors suggest an innate capacity for awe, grief, and connection that could evolve into faith-like constructs. Viewing animals as potential believers enriches our understanding of spirituality as a universal evolutionary trait, not a human monopoly. As research advances, we may discover that the divine whispers across species, uniting us in a shared tapestry of wonder.